Creamy Smoked Fish Pie

Comforting, warming and utterly delicious Creamy Smoked Fish Pie is a classic of the British kitchen for good reason. Deeply satisfying and full of healthy omega-3 oils, this is real good mood food.

Though there are many (unfair) jokes about British cooking, when it comes to fabulous rib-sticking pub food, they are the undisputed winners. I’m talking comfort-food classics like Sunday Roast with all the trimmings, Bread and Butter Pudding or today’s recipe: Creamy Smoked Fish Pie.

Creamy Smoked Fish Pie fresh out of the oven with creamy mash on top and a parsley garnish.

Pub Food = Comfort food

I lived in London for a few years back in the ’00s and travel there frequently. In fact, I lived there again in 2023 while I studied cooking at Le Cordon Bleu Cooking school (dreams do come true!)

It was while living in the UK that I developed a love of real British pub food. Made with a bit of care and attention, these recipes can absolutely shine.

Yes, smoked fish pie can be truly gruesome if it comes in a microwave packet, but if you make it yourself, with a mixture of smoked fish, white fish and other seafood, it is absolutely dreamy.

White fish, smoked mackerel and smoked salmon.
Use a mixture of fish for best flavour – today I used cod, mackerel and salmon, as well as shrimp/prawns.

Ingredients

To make Smoked Fish Pie, you’ll need the following main ingredients:

  • FISH: The star of the show. I use a firm white fish such as cod, an oily smoked fish such as mackerel, salmon or both and some seafood. Prawns or shrimp are delicious and affordable, but if you want to really push the boat out (Dad joke alert!) adding scallops to this dish makes it incredibly luxurious.
  • POTATOES: You’ll need floury mashing potatoes to make fish pie.
  • Butter, milk and cream: This is comfort food! That means plenty of the good stuff. If you are watching your weight you can use fat reduced versions of these ingredients.
  • WHITE WINE: Adding a little white wine or vermouth to fish pie makes it even more delicious. If you are making it alcohol-free, replace it with milk instead.

The recipe card at the bottom of the page contains the complete ingredient list and instructions.

Ingredients for Creamy Smoked Fish Pie. Potatoes, Parsley, Fish and seafood.

Feed a family

My Smoked Fish Pie recipe will comfortably feed four people. I like to make it in a big dish and scoop out big, loose spoonfuls, this is the kind of food that you don’t need a knife for after all!

Creamy Smoked Fish Pie showing filling under mashed potatoes.

Variations

Fish Pie for a Dinner Party: If you are serving fish pie for a dinner party and want it to look a bit tidier, use the same filling but make it in individual pie dishes or ramekins.

It’s brilliant for preparing in advance, so you can just whack it in the oven when your guests arrive and enjoy a drink with your friends, while the house fills with gloriously inviting aromas.

How to make Fish Pie with Pastry: While it is traditional to make this as a ‘pot pie’ with a potato topping and no bottom pastry, you can absolutely use this filling in a traditional double-crust pie. Follow the instructions in my recipe for Creamy Chicken Pie here, just swap out the fillings.

Creamy Smoked Fish Pie showing shrimp n the creamy sauce.

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

What sort of fish should I use in Creamy Smoked Fish Pie?

I like to use a mixture, some plain white fish fillets such as cod, some hot smoked fish such as salmon, mackerel or both and some other seafood. Prawns are traditional, but scallops are lovely if the budget will stretch that far!

Can I use frozen fish to make fish pie?

Absolutely! In fact, I recommend it! You can use the fish directly from frozen, just poach it as per the recipe in the milk. Check to make sure it flakes easily – if not, you’ll need to simmer it a minute or two longer.

Can fish pie be frozen?

Yes, though if you are freezing it I would recommend making it in individual dishes or ramekins as it will store better. Mashed potato can change texture once frozen unless it has plenty of butter and milk or cream in it, so put plenty in!

Looking for more delicious pie recipes? Try my Creamy Chicken Pie or Beef and Lentil Cottage Pie recipes! Fancy something different? Try Tiropita (Greek Cheese Pies)!

Creamy Smoked Fish Pie

You can even cook the fish directly from frozen! Cook as per the recipe, then check to see if the fish flakes easily. If not, cook it a minute or two longer.

Creamy Smoked Fish Pie on a plate with peas.

Creamy Smoked Fish Pie Recipe

Creamy Smoked Fish Pie with golden mash and three types of seafood.

Creamy Smoked Fish Pie

Jay Wadams
Comforting, warming and utterly delicious Creamy Smoked Fish Pie is a classic of the British kitchen for good reason. Deeply satisfying and full of healthy omega-3 oils, this is real good mood food.
4.67 from 9 votes
Prep Time 20 minutes
Cook Time 1 hour 15 minutes
Total Time 1 hour 35 minutes
Serves 4

Ingredients
 

for the topping:

  • 1 kg floury potatoes
  • 125 ml whole milk
  • 50 g butter

for the filling:

  • 500 g firm white fish
  • 250 g hot-smoked fish, eg: salmon, mackerel or both
  • 300 ml whole milk
  • 1 bay leaf
  • 75 g butter
  • 1 small leek, halved and sliced
  • 50 g plain or all-purpose flour
  • 125 ml white wine
  • 175 ml whipping cream
  • 2 tsp Dijon mustard
  • 250 g cooked, peeled prawns (shrimp)
  • small bunch fresh parsley, finely chopped
  • sea salt and black pepper

Instructions
 

  • COOK POTATOES: Cook the potatoes in plenty of salted water until tender. Drain, mash, then beat in the milk and butter until smooth. Season to taste with salt and pepper then set aside. Heat oven to 200°C / 400°F / Gas 6.
  • POACH FISH: Place fish in a saucepan in one layer. Pour over the milk, add the bay leaf, then season with salt and pepper. Cover and bring to a simmer, then turn the heat right down to low and simmer for 4-5 minutes.
  • SAUTÉ LEEK: Strain the fish, reserving the milk. Flake the fish into large chunks. Rinse the saucepan and wipe it dry, then heat 25g of the butter until bubbling. Cook the leek for 2-3 minutes, just until softened, then remove with a slotted spoon.
  • MAKE WHITE SAUCE: Melt the remaining butter and flour together in the same saucepan. Allow to cook, stirring all the time, for 3 minutes. Pour in the milk and white wine, beating until smooth. Add the cream and mustard and cook until thick. This will take around 10 minutes, make sure to stir from time to time to prevent the sauce from catching. Season with salt and pepper.
  • COMBINE INGREDIENTS: Add fish, prawns (shrimp) and parsley, stir to combine and remove from heat. Pour into the baking dish and spoon over the mashed potato, spreading it out to cover the filling.
  • BAKE: Place on a baking tray (this is important! Fish pie bubbles over 100% of the time!) and bake in the preheated oven 40-45 minutes until golden and beginning to crisp on the top. Allow to cool for five minutes before serving.

Notes

Don't forget to place a tray under the fish pie in the oven! They always bubble over a little and it will catch the sauce so it doesn't burn onto the floor of your oven!
Imperial and cup measurements are approximate. For best and most accurate results I use and recommend a digital kitchen scale like the one below.

Recommended Equipment

As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Nutrition

Serving: 1slice | Calories: 944kcal | Carbohydrates: 64g | Protein: 55g | Fat: 52g | Saturated Fat: 30g | Polyunsaturated Fat: 4g | Monounsaturated Fat: 13g | Trans Fat: 1g | Cholesterol: 292mg | Sodium: 780mg | Potassium: 2176mg | Fiber: 6g | Sugar: 9g | Vitamin A: 2186IU | Vitamin C: 55mg | Calcium: 288mg | Iron: 5mg
Tried this recipe?Leave a review or a star rating and let me know how it was! Use the hashtag #daysofjay on Instagram so I can see your delicious creations.
Course | Main Course
Cuisine | British
SHARE THIS RECIPE:
Jay Wadams
Jay Wadams

Jay Wadams is a cookbook author, food photographer and Le Cordon Bleu Gastronomy and Nutrition graduate. Based in Italy 🇮🇹 Germany 🇩🇪 and Australia 🇦🇺.

Articles: 339

6 Comments

  1. Very nice recipe. I used what I had on hand which was the Smoked salmon and shrimp, I subbed parsley with a little dried dill and a shallot instead of leek. Still came out wonderful, thank you.

    • Hi Georgina! Thank you so much for taking the time to write such a lovely comment. I love the sound of using a little dill in there, I bet it tasted delicious with that smoked salmon! I’m so glad you enjoyed the recipe. All the very best for 2022! J.

  2. Lieber Jay mir läuft das Wasser im Mund zusammen .So köstlich diese Pastete. Werde ich bald wieder kochen. Sehr gut!

  3. 5 stars
    My first attempt at fish pie was a hit with everyone! Your recipe was easy to follow, and I was pleasantly surprised that the white sauce turned out well on the first try (I am usually terrible with making white sauce). We were gifted smoked trout by our very kind neighbor, and I was at a loss as to what to do with it until I found this. Even my six year old and my husband who is picky about fish loved it.

    • Hi Jess, thank you so much for your lovely comment, it has made my day! What a great use for smoked trout (yum, lucky you!) I am so happy that this recipe worked out so well for you and that the whole family enjoyed it! J.

4.67 from 9 votes (8 ratings without comment)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating